In a developing AFL rumour that’s gaining traction, Collingwood Football Club may once again set its sights on Ben McKay, the towering key defender who joined Essendon in 2023 via free agency.
While McKay is currently contracted at the Bombers, insiders suggest that his future may not be as cemented as once thought. If Essendon undergoes a structural reshuffle in their backline or if McKay struggles to consistently lock down a spot in Brad Scott’s best 22, a trade scenario could come into play. And if that happens, the Magpies will be one of the first clubs knocking at the door.
📌 Why Would Collingwood Target McKay?
Collingwood has made no secret of their interest in bolstering their defensive depth — especially key-position defenders. With Billy Frampton dealing with inconsistent form and Nathan Murphy facing ongoing concussion concerns, the Magpies are assessing long-term solutions for a reliable intercepting tall.
McKay, standing at 202cm, fits that mould perfectly. A natural key back with the ability to play lockdown roles on elite forwards, his intercept work and aerial presence would complement Darcy Moore and Oleg Markov nicely. Collingwood had interest in McKay before he made the switch to Essendon and that door may not be fully closed.
🔍 Contract & Status Overview
•Current Club: Essendon Bombers
•Contract: Multi-year deal signed in 2023
•Availability: Not on the market — but could become part of future trade speculation
•Potential Exit Trigger: Team reshuffle, reduced playing time, or cap space adjustment
🎯 Summary
•Ben McKay to Collingwood is not a confirmed move, but it’s a speculative watchlist development worth tracking.
•With a growing need for a long-term key defender and a history of interest in McKay, Collingwood may pounce if an opportunity arises.
•Essendon holds the cards for now, but player movement and club needs can change fast in the AFL.
🗣️ What They’re Saying
•“Collingwood is always keeping one eye on the future, and McKay remains a player they admire. If the Bombers can’t make it work, expect the Pies to be right there.” – AFL Trade Analyst
Keep an eye on this one — it might just become one of the most intriguing trade stories heading into the 2025 off-season.