Brandon Austin of Pro Football Network placed Callahan at No. 24 out of 25 returners, just ahead of only Giants coach Brian Daboll. He noted:
•Callahan’s debut campaign with a 3–14 record was “uninspiring,” especially considering his pedigree as an offensive guru from the Zac Taylor tree.
•Despite struggling QBs like Mason Rudolph and Will Levis, the expectations were modest—and Callahan still underdelivered.
•A redemption arc may be possible with rookie QB Cam Ward, but his seat remains far from secure.
🏈 Season Performance & Hot-Seat Talk
•In 2024, Callahan led the Titans to the league’s worst record, and publicly described it as “embarrassing”.
•That marked a disappointing follow-up to a 6–11 season in 2023, leading analysts to question whether the Titans should move on rather than extend a rebuild.
🔍 Key Failures Under Callahan
A USA Today deep dive highlighted critical shortcomings:
•Offensive Decline: No improvement in scoring or efficiency—still bottom‑10 in points (18.3 ppg), total yards (304.2), and passing (195.1 ypg).
•In‑Game Mismanagement: Questionable fourth‑down decisions and poor clock management cost games.
•Discipline Issues: High penalty rate—among league‑worst.
•Special Teams Woes: One of the worst units in returns allowed.
🗣️ Locker Room Sentiment
Mixed vibes from players and fans:
•Some credit Callahan with building resilience, calmness, and player-first culture.
•Others criticize his lack of identity, poor decision-making, and no offensive spark.
🔥 Hot Seat or Redemption Story?
•According to SI, the Titans kept Callahan around, banking on his improved roster and rookie QB to show progress this season.
•But his ranking at No. 24 signals league-wide skepticism: the next year is critical, and another failure could land him firmly on the chopping block.
🧩 Putting It All Together
1.League rank: Bottom‑tier among experienced coaches.
2.Track record: 3‑14 in debut, offensive regression, strategic miscues.
3.Culture: Mixed—some appreciate it, others lament the lack of identity.
4.Future outlook: 2025 is do-or-die with Cam Ward and upgraded talent needing to show real results.
🗳️ Your Turn, Titans Nation:
•Do you believe in giving Callahan more time with a better roster and QB?
•Or should the Titans be ruthless and move on if they don’t see major improvements in 2025?