“He’s been a warrior in our system – now it’s time for the next man up.”
It’s a gutting piece of news for Collingwood fans — Billy Frampton, who’s quietly become a vital cog in Craig McRae’s defensive structure, is set for a stint on the sidelines after suffering a moderate-grade calf strain. He’s expected to miss multiple weeks, and while the setback stings, it also forces the Pies into a fascinating selection call.
Since slotting into the side early this season, Frampton has done everything asked of him and more. Whether it’s nullifying dangerous key forwards, crashing packs, or executing “Fly’s” team-first defensive system to perfection, Billy’s presence down back has been rock solid. His ability to win one-on-ones and support intercept roles made him a dependable piece behind the ball.
But with Frampton out, the next man up is about to get a chance. So… who should it be?
Options to Cover Frampton’s Absence:
1. Charlie Dean
The most natural replacement. After a run of bad luck with injuries, Dean has been building strong form in the VFL. A true key defender with clean marking hands and positional smarts, Dean could finally get his long-awaited shot at consistent senior footy. This is a golden chance for him to prove his resilience and value.
2. Nathan Murphy (if fit)
If Murphy’s recovery timeline aligns, he’d be the immediate plug-in. A proven finals performer with a fearless attitude, Murphy slots straight into the backline if medically cleared. But it all hinges on his concussion management protocols.
3. Jeremy Howe
If Fly wants a more experienced solution, Howe could be swung back into a full-time key defensive role, even if it’s slightly undersized. His leadership and aerial impact help offset size mismatches. But it could compromise his usual intercept role if mismanaged.
4. Recruit from the VFL: Wil Parker or Jakob Ryan
While raw, both players have shown glimpses of AFL readiness. Parker is agile and composed, and Ryan is a versatile backman who brings attacking flair. It’d be bold — but bold is in McRae’s coaching DNA.
The Bigger Picture:
While Frampton’s loss is significant, it’s also a reminder of the squad depth Collingwood has built under McRae. Whether it’s Dean, Murphy, or a new face stepping up, the Pies will back their system over individuals. That’s been their trademark.
Frampton will be missed — but the door is open. Who wants it more?
#GoPies #InjuryUpdate #NextManUp #FramptonOut #AFL2025
