In a major development from AFL House, the AFL Tribunal has officially dismissed the charge against Collingwood key forward Daniel McStay, who was cited for tripping during the fourth quarter of Round 15 in the clash between Collingwood and St Kilda.
The incident in question occurred late in the match, when McStay was alleged to have deliberately tripped a St Kilda player during a contested play. The Match Review Officer assessed the incident and referred it to the Tribunal under the league’s guidelines for potential misconduct.
However, in the Tribunal’s written submission outcome released today, it was confirmed that the charge has been dismissed, clearing McStay of any wrongdoing. After reviewing the available footage, hearing testimony, and assessing the nature of the contact, the Tribunal ruled that the incident did not warrant a suspension or fine. The panel concluded that McStay’s action was “not careless, intentional or unreasonable in the circumstances of play.”
This decision comes as a relief for the Magpies, who are already navigating a challenging period with several key players sidelined due to injury. McStay’s availability for the upcoming rounds is a significant boost for Collingwood’s forward structure as they push for a top-four finish.
The club issued a brief statement following the verdict:
“We respect the Tribunal process and are pleased with today’s outcome. Daniel is an important part of our group, and we now turn our full attention to this week’s game.”
This ruling also highlights the AFL’s ongoing commitment to due process and fair play, ensuring that players are judged on clear evidence and context rather than assumptions.
© AFL House / 2025
